Apple sues OpenAI and two ex-Apple engineers
Including hardware chief Tang Tan, for trade-secret theft over AI devices
Confirmed
Importance: major (4 of 5)Status
- Claim
Confirmed
- Our reporting
- High confidence
- Importance
- Major (4 of 5)
- Last verified
- 15 October 2026
Your AI and this story
- GPT-6.2 Astra40 days after its cutoff
- Claude Opus 5.510 days after its cutoff
- Gemini 4 Hydrogen101 days after its cutoff
- Grok 4.740 days after its cutoff
None of these four assistants can know about it. The closest, Claude Opus 5.5, stops 10 days before it.
Key facts
- Filed July 10, 2026, US District Court for the Northern District of California
- Complaint: ‘at every level, from members of its Technical Staff to its Chief Hardware Officer, and in coordination with business partners, OpenAI has been stealing Apple’s trade secrets and confidential information’ (CNBC)
- Tang Tan (24 years at Apple, led iPhone/Apple Watch product design; OpenAI Chief Hardware Officer): accused of using Apple project code names in recruiting, asking candidates to bring Apple components to interviews, coaching departing staff on evading security and emailing himself supplier information (TechCrunch, Axios)
- Chang Liu (8 years at Apple, senior systems electrical engineer): accused of keeping an Apple laptop and downloading confidential technical documents
- Alleged material: technical specifications, engineering presentations, component and vendor selection, a proprietary metal-finishing technique
- Defendants: TechCrunch’s launch report said io (Jony Ive’s company, bought by OpenAI in 2025 for $6.5B) was not named; later 9to5Mac/CNBC coverage lists io Products among the defendants (likely added later; unverified)
- OpenAI on X: ‘We have no interest in other companies’ trade secrets’
- Relief: injunction barring use/disclosure, return of materials, evidence preservation; Apple moved for a preliminary injunction
Show 5 more
- Sept 2026: Apple’s reply brief added five expert declarations (126 pages); OpenAI (Sept 25) accused Apple of ‘sandbagging’ with new evidence; Apple (Oct 5) said OpenAI’s objection improperly added new argument and an eight-paragraph Liu declaration
- Preliminary-injunction hearing: Oct 14, 2026 (9to5Mac)
- Oct 13, 2026 (Bloomberg Law): Judge Edward J. Davila partly granted Apple’s motion for expedited discovery. OpenAI must hand over forensic images of devices, summaries of certain employee interviews, LINE conversations between former Apple employees Chang Liu and Alyssa Peng, and documents on the former employees’ roles at OpenAI. The judge cited a risk that forensic evidence could be destroyed, pointing to a conversation between Liu and Peng about wiping Apple-owned devices, and wrote that the secrets may become ‘so deeply entangled with OpenAI’s hardware products or other research and development efforts that the harm cannot be undone’. He denied expedited discovery into OpenAI’s R&D on metal finishes, power management and batteries, and put off requests built on the term ‘Apple Originated Information’ as ‘amorphous as currently defined’. OpenAI calls the suit baseless. The hearing on the motion to dismiss and the preliminary injunction is on Oct 14
- More on the Oct 13 order (9to5Mac, TechCrunch): it also covers interview materials of OpenAI’s Consumer Hardware Products Group for Apple candidates (checklists, guides, scripts, ‘Technical Deep Dive’ presentations, records that refer to Apple technology or parts) and approves depositions of Chang Liu, Alyssa Peng and Tang Tan (OpenAI’s chief hardware officer), plus corporate representatives of OpenAI and io Products. TechCrunch: OpenAI has five days to produce material already collected and 14 days for the rest; Apple has five days to file a narrower definition of ‘Apple Originated Information’. Denied requests (OpenAI hardware R&D, what former employees built at OpenAI) can be narrowed and refiled
- Oct 14, 2026 (OpenAI filing, reported by Reuters, 9to5Mac, The Verge): OpenAI alleges that an unnamed engineer who joined OpenAI from Apple, stayed about six months and returned to Apple sent ‘over a hundred highly confidential files’ on at least one unreleased OpenAI device to personal accounts on June 2, 2026, his last day (device images, engineering and manufacturing data, supplier information, cosmetic-finish standards, coating and sealing reports), and later presented OpenAI’s plans to Apple senior leadership, including Apple’s VP of operations in Asia. OpenAI says the claims come from ‘a recent and ongoing forensic investigation’ and that Apple refused to give assurances it does not hold or use OpenAI’s secrets. Apple told Reuters it found no evidence supporting the allegations
What happened
Apple, once OpenAI’s ChatGPT partner in iOS, sued OpenAI over its hardware program. The complaint centres on Tang Tan, who ran product design at Apple before co-founding io with Jony Ive and becoming OpenAI’s hardware chief, and on engineer Chang Liu. Apple says the recruiting of Apple staff was used to obtain confidential designs and supplier information for OpenAI’s devices. The case has since turned into a fight over Apple’s preliminary-injunction motion, with both sides accusing the other of improper late filings.
Why it matters
It is the most direct legal clash between Apple and an AI lab, and it could slow OpenAI’s first consumer devices (a pocket-sized Ive device was expected in early 2027). Added on Oct 6, 2026 as a backfill: the dataset had missed the July filing until the Oct 5 filing surfaced.
Sources
12 sources from 8 sites. Numbers match the chips in the text.
12 sources: 12 press
Press
- TechCrunch: Apple sues OpenAI over alleged trade secret theft (Jul 10)techcrunch.com, press
- CNBC: Apple sues OpenAI alleging trade secret theft, says scheme was ‘at every level’cnbc.com, press
- Axios: Apple sues OpenAI for trade secret theftaxios.com, press
- Bloomberg: Apple sues OpenAI for trade secret theft over AI hardware designsbloomberg.com, press
- 9to5Mac: OpenAI accuses Apple of improperly adding new evidence (Sept 25)9to5mac.com, press
- 9to5Mac: Apple accuses OpenAI of improperly adding new arguments (Oct 5)9to5mac.com, press
- Bloomberg Law: Apple wins early access to OpenAI files in trade secrets suit (Oct 13)news.bloomberglaw.com, press
- 9to5Mac: Apple wins early access to OpenAI documents and employee testimony (Oct 13)9to5mac.com, press
- TechCrunch: Judge orders OpenAI to turn over hiring records in Apple trade secrets case (Oct 13)techcrunch.com, press
- Reuters: OpenAI employee who left for Apple took files about unreleased device, OpenAI alleges (Oct 14)reuters.com, press
- 9to5Mac: OpenAI alleges ex-employee took ‘highly confidential’ device files to Apple (Oct 14)9to5mac.com, press
- The Verge: OpenAI claims an ex-employee took its product plans and presented them to Apple (Oct 14)theverge.com, press
Changes
- Linked the Oct 14 hearing outcome (OpenAI’s voluntary no-use agreement; judge ‘highly likely’ to grant injunction), see
[OpenAI agrees not to use alleged Apple trade secrets at hearing](/e/2026-10-14-openai-agrees-not-to-use-apple-trade-secrets-hearing/) - OpenAI’s Oct 14 counter-allegation that an ex-employee took device files to Apple
- Details of the Oct 13 order from 9to5Mac and TechCrunch (interview materials, depositions of Liu, Peng and Tang Tan, deadlines)
- Added Judge Davila’s expedited-discovery order (Bloomberg Law)
- Filed (found through the Oct 5 9to5Mac report)