Conjectures.io bounty platform pays out for Lean proofs of Erdős #859, #18(b), #1062(ii) and Ben Green’s problems 24, 39, 40 within ten days, mostly to Purdue’s ‘JenW1N’
Awaiting review
The takeaway
Between Sept 15 and Sept 25, 2026, Conjectures.io paid bounties for machine-checked Lean proofs of seven formalised open problems.
Status
- Claim
Awaiting review
- Our reporting
- Medium confidence
- Verification
- Lean-verified
- Importance
- 3 of 5
- Last verified
- 5 October 2026
Your AI and this story
- GPT-6.2 Astra117 days after its cutoff
- Claude Opus 5.587 days after its cutoff
- Gemini 4 Hydrogen178 days after its cutoff
- Grok 4.7117 days after its cutoff
None of these four assistants can know about it. The closest, Claude Opus 5.5, stops 87 days before it.
Key facts
- Results page (Oct 5, 2026): 26 problems solved, 33 verified proofs, $129,963 (127,226.57 α) paid, 257 live bounties; two submissions rejected (Erdős #70, #252) as already solved/formalised; Erdős #579 (by ‘Jordan’, Oct 3) pending review. (The lead recorded $127,713 earlier the same day; the total moves with the token price)
- Erdős #18(b), JenW1N, Sept 16, $3,232: proves h(n!) < n^ε for every ε > 0 and large n (h(m) = number of divisors needed to represent every 1 ≤ k < m as a sum of distinct divisors of a practical m); Lean file 14,043 lines. Erdős had shown h(n!) < n
- Erdős #859, JenW1N, Sept 18, $3,820: the density d_t of n for which t is a sum of distinct divisors of n satisfies d_t ~ c₁/(log t)^c₂ (Erdős 1970 had only bounds of this shape); Lean file 36,197 lines
- Erdős #1062(ii), JenW1N, Sept 21, $4,007: on fork-free subsets of {1,…,n} (no a | b and a | c), whether lim f(n)/n is irrational (Guy’s problem B24); Lean file 74,209 lines; the page itself notes that ‘a complete ordinary-kernel check and target axiom audit are still required’
- Green’s open problem 24, JenW1N, Sept 25, $4,247: a (1/3 + o(1))n² asymptotic from Ben Green’s list of 100 open problems; 52,946 lines of Lean; disclosure: ‘OpenAI ChatGPT/Codex assisted with the mathematics, certificate generation, Lean formalization, verification, and presentation’
- Green’s open problem 40, JenW1N, Sept 15, $4,436; Green’s open problem 39, ‘Jordan’, Sept 19, $2,793
- Platform model: ‘checking a proof takes seconds where finding one can take months’; accepts proofs made with ‘any AI, tool, or method’; payment only after Lean kernel check against the pinned statement plus human review for gaming or plagiarism
- erdosproblems.com on Oct 5, 2026: #18 OPEN with 3 proof claims, #859 OPEN with 1 proof claim, #1062 OPEN with 1 proof claim, #579 OPEN with none
What happened
After the Erdős #108 disproof (Sept 15), the same two-person Purdue team kept claiming Conjectures.io bounties. They took several number-theory problems on divisors and practical numbers that Erdős posed in the 1970s, plus three problems from Ben Green’s list. Each solution is a single Lean file checked against the platform’s pinned formal statement, and the platform describes it in a write-up. Rewards were paid in Bittensor alpha, worth about $2.8k–4.4k per problem.
We read the solution pages through a summarising fetcher. Exact statements, especially the precise formal form of #1062(ii) and Green 24, should be checked against the pinned Lean targets.
Why it matters
A crypto-funded bounty market is now paying for formal proofs of open problems, and AI-assisted solvers are collecting the payouts in days. The Lean check guarantees that the pinned statement was proved. It does not guarantee that the statement matches what Erdős or Green meant, or that mathematicians find the proof illuminating. Graph theorists raised the same complaint about the #108 write-up. Watch whether erdosproblems.com accepts the claims.
What is disputed or not yet verified
| Verification | Lean kernel check against pinned bounty statements plus platform human review; no peer review; erdosproblems.com has not yet marked them solved |
|---|
Sources
8 sources from 2 sites. Numbers match the chips in the text.
8 sources: 5 primary, 3 reactions
Primary
- Conjectures.io resultsconjectures.io, official
- Conjectures.io: Erdős #18(b) solutionconjectures.io, code
- Conjectures.io: Erdős #859 solutionconjectures.io, code
- Conjectures.io: Erdős #1062(ii) solutionconjectures.io, code
- Conjectures.io: Green’s open problem 24 solutionconjectures.io, code
Reactions
- erdosproblems.com #18erdosproblems.com, discussion
- erdosproblems.com #859erdosproblems.com, discussion
- erdosproblems.com #1062erdosproblems.com, discussion
Changes
- Filed. Confidence medium: statements summarised from platform pages, no expert confirmation yet