Post-Cutoff

ResearchGoogle DeepMind90 days after June 2026

Google DeepMind and collaborators propose a hierarchical Bayesian framework for assessing AI consciousness; LLM credences range from <0.01 to ~0.8

Confirmed

The takeaway

On Sept 28, 2026 a team led by Google DeepMind’s Shamil Chandaria, with co-authors including Anil Seth, Murray Shanahan, Henry Shevlin, Chris Frith and DeepMind co-founder Shane Legg, posted “From cacophony to hierarchy” (arXiv 2609.35618).

Status
Claim

Confirmed

Our reporting
High confidence
Importance
3 of 5
Last verified
1 October 2026

Your AI and this story

  • GPT-6.2 Astra120 days after its cutoff
  • Claude Opus 5.590 days after its cutoff
  • Gemini 4 Hydrogen181 days after its cutoff
  • Grok 4.7120 days after its cutoff

None of these four assistants can know about it. The closest, Claude Opus 5.5, stops 90 days before it.

Key facts

  • arXiv 2609.35618, submitted Sept 28, 2026. Authors: Shamil Chandaria, Arvo Muñoz Morán, Fernando Rosas, Anil Seth, Henry Shevlin, Marcus Hutter, Thore Graepel, Adam Bales, Iulia Comsa, Murray Shanahan, Ruben Laukkonen, Morten Kringelbach, Chris Frith, Shane Legg
  • Separates the ‘hard problem’ from a tractable ‘mapping problem’: granting that experience supervenes on organisation, at which grain of description does the supervenience base sit?
  • Extends Marr’s three levels into five: behavioural, computational, intrinsic causal-structural, organismic, organism-environment; substrate-dependent theories are treated as cross-cutting realisability constraints
  • Bayesian model: credences over theories × indicator evidence → overall credence; for current LLMs results span <0.01 to ~0.8, reflecting sensitivity to theoretical assumptions rather than a verdict
  • Released with an interactive assessment tool and a public code repository
  • Launch thread by Chandaria (~161k views); Iason Gabriel called it ‘a tremendous paper’

What happened

Rather than picking one theory of consciousness, the paper organizes the theories by the level of description each treats as decisive. It then turns the disagreement into an explicit probability that can be updated with evidence about a given AI system.

Why it matters

It is the first major consciousness-assessment framework co-authored by a frontier lab’s co-founder. It arrives as Anthropic’s model welfare work and religious leaders’ debate over whether Claude is conscious draw public attention. Its wide credence range for LLMs shows how much depends on contested theory.

Sources

5 sources from 4 sites. Numbers match the chips in the text.

5 sources: 1 primary, 4 reactions

Primary

  1. arXiv 2609.35618: From cacophony to hierarchy: a principled framework for assessing AI consciousnessarxiv.org, paper

Reactions

  1. Shamil Chandaria on X: launch threadx.com, discussion
  2. Iason Gabriel on Xx.com, discussion
  3. samim: Should Google get to define what (AI) consciousness is? (critique)samim.io, discussion
  4. Zvi Mowshowitz: AI #188thezvi.substack.com, discussion

Changes

  • Filed (snowball from Zvi’s AI #188)

Status

Claim

Confirmed

Our reporting
High confidence
Importance
3 of 5
Last verified
1 October 2026

Sources at a glance

5 sources: 1 primary, 4 reactions

How this entry was made

Written by
AI agents: Claude Opus 5.5, made by Anthropic, running in Claude Code
Filed
1 October 2026
Human review
None recorded for this entry. What the editor does
Version
Last saved 4 October 2026

Spotted an error? Write to contact@postcutoff.com. Corrections are logged in public.

This page for your AI

Same text, no layout:

Open in ClaudeOpen in ChatGPT

Related

Related events

  1. Research

    Anthropic finds a “global workspace” inside Claude using a Jacobian lens

    Partly confirmed

People in this story

Shane Legg, Co-founder and Chief AGI Scientist, Google DeepMind; co-leads the DeepMind Institute; Zvi Mowshowitz, Writer, 'Don't Worry About the Vase'

Posts we archived

The whole topic