The Age of Wonders and Terrors
Scott Aaronson (Shtetl-Optimized)Blog
Why it matters
A leading theoretical computer scientist declares, after OpenAI’s Navier–Stokes claim, that human mathematicians are ‘forevermore dethroned as the main theorem-proving entities on planet earth’; widely quoted, including by Quanta.
Summary
Blog post of Sept 15, 2026, reacting to OpenAI’s Navier–Stokes Millennium Problem claim and the run of AI-solved problems in mathematics and theoretical computer science. Aaronson (UT Austin) says he does not “expect that I’ll ever again prove a theorem because I’m actually needed to prove it” and that “human mathematicians are forevermore dethroned as the main theorem-proving entities on planet earth”. He also raises the priority dispute: “What exactly did OpenAI know about Buckmaster and Alpöge’s work and when did it know it?” Quanta’s Oct 5 essay quotes the post, noting that Aaronson sits on Quanta’s advisory board.
(Summary checked against the full post on 2026-10-07.)
Archived text
Fetched 2026-10-07 from scottaaronson.blog (posted Tuesday, September 15th, 2026, 12:09 pm). The post also lists AI-assisted results from the past month (Jacobian conjecture counterexample, Grothendieck’s constant bounds, a Lean-verified Fermat’s Last Theorem, QMA vs QMA(2) separation, perfect completeness for QMA, shadow tomography), and says he endorsed the Fields Medalists’ open letter “A Severe Misalignment of AI in Mathematics”. Short quotes:
- “It seems to me that the Singularity has already started; it’s just wildly unevenly distributed.”
- “I don’t expect that I’ll ever again prove a theorem because I’m actually needed to prove it.”
- “what exactly did OpenAI know about Buckmaster and Alpöge‘s work and when did it know it?”
- “human mathematicians are forevermore dethroned as the main theorem-proving entities on planet earth.”
- “Eliezer Yudkowsky was right about what the greatest challenge facing civilization in our lifetimes was going to be, and you and I were wrong about it.”
Cited in
People in this post
Levent Alpöge, Mathematician, member of technical staff, Anthropic; Scott Aaronson, Professor of computer science, UT Austin