Michael Smith sentenced to 18 months in the first US criminal case over AI-generated music and bot streams
On Oct 6, 2026 Judge John G. Koeltl (SDNY) sentenced Michael Smith, 54, of North Carolina, to 18 months in prison and $8.09M forfeiture for using thousands of bot accounts to stream hundreds of thousands of mostly AI-generated songs billions of times on Spotify, Apple Music, Amazon Music and YouTube Music from 2017 to 2024, collecting more than $8M in royalties. It was the first criminal prosecution of AI-assisted streaming fraud in the US.
Key facts
- Sentence: 18 months in prison, 2 years supervised release, forfeiture of $8,091,843.64 (DOJ)
- Plea: guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, March 19, 2026; first charged Sept 2024
- Prosecutors asked for 46 months; probation recommended 24; the defense asked for probation, arguing the field was 'largely unregulated' (Inner City Press courtroom report)
- Judge Koeltl said the guideline range was 'somewhat inflated' and that the case was about fake bot streams, not about the AI-made music itself (Inner City Press)
- Scale example (Digital Music News): in April 2023 Smith's bots produced 80.9M YouTube Music streams, vs 9.3M for Taylor Swift's whole catalog
- DOJ wording: the SDNY release calls it 'super intelligence-assisted' fraud, following Trump's Sept 29 renaming order and the DOJ's Oct 6 memo
What happened
Smith uploaded large numbers of AI-generated tracks and ran bot accounts that streamed them nonstop, so the streaming services paid him royalties that would otherwise have gone to real artists. The Billboard and Rolling Stone articles are paywalled; this entry is written from the DOJ release as reported, Digital Music News and an Inner City Press courtroom report.
Why it matters
It is the first US prison sentence for streaming fraud built on AI-generated music, and it sets a benchmark for a kind of fraud that cheap music generators make easy.
Changelog
- 2026-10-07: created
People
Related events
- Trump signs executive order 'Inaugurating the Era of Super Intelligence', ordering federal agencies to replace 'AI' with 'Super Intelligence (SI)' ★★★
- Suno adds audio watermarking, fingerprinting and download limits amid lawsuits ★★
Sources (6)
- officialDOJ SDNY: North Carolina man sentenced to 18 months in prison for super intelligence-assisted music streaming fraud
- officialDOJ SDNY (March 2026): North Carolina man pleads guilty to music streaming fraud aided by artificial intelligence
- pressBillboard: AI music streaming fraudster sentenced to 1.5 years in prison for $8M royalties scam
- pressDigital Music News: Streaming fraudster Michael Smith sentenced to 18 months
- pressRolling Stone: Mike Smith sentenced to 18 months in major music streaming fraud case
- pressInner City Press: courtroom report on the sentencing
id: 2026-10-06-michael-smith-ai-music-streaming-fraud-sentenced · updated 2026-10-07 · open in the interactive timeline