Post-Cutoff

OpenAI is “burning down” CoT monitoring with Astra

Rob Wiblin @robertwiblinX

Why it matters

A widely quoted one-line reaction (80,000 Hours host) that framed the Astra controversy as the loss of chain-of-thought monitoring; Gary Marcus and others repeated the phrase.

Summary

The day after Astra’s launch, Wiblin wrote that OpenAI had decided to stay competitive by burning down “the only meaningful bit of safety assurance we actually have today - CoT monitoring”, calling it “completely disastrous”. The target is Astra’s recurrent-depth (“looped”) reasoning, which OpenAI’s own system card says makes chain-of-thought monitors less reliable. The phrasing was reused in Gary Marcus’s “Pause OpenAI, now” the same day. Verified via the X syndication API (2026-09-04 08:27 UTC).

Archived text

Despite everything that has happened, OpenAI has seemingly decided to stay competitive by burning down the only meaningful bit of safety assurance we actually have today - CoT monitoring.

Completely disastrous.

Quoting @RyanGreenblatt: GPT-6 Astra appears to be a massive jump in opaque reasoning ability: it looks like it can solve hard competition math problems entirely in its head (as in, without verbalized reasoning) while prior AIs could solve basic word problems.

This seems extremely concerning!

That is, https://t.co/Pjg5keuK5O

Source: x.com/robertwiblin/status/2095790774482817059Archived 2026-09-29 via syndication.Counts: 427 likes, 16 replies (at fetch time)

Cited in

  1. Model releases 65 days after the cutoff

    OpenAI releases GPT-6 Astra, its first GPT-6 model

People in this post

Gary Marcus, Cognitive scientist and author; professor emeritus, NYU