Post-Cutoff

Commentator

Gary Marcus

Cognitive scientist and author; professor emeritus, NYU, as of 4 October 2026. Source: en.wikipedia.org

The best-known skeptic of deep learning and LLM hype; testified to the US Senate in 2023.

In the news

8 events on Post-Cutoff name Gary Marcus, newest first.

  1. Science & math 98 days after the cutoff

    OpenAI releases 722 AI-written math manuscripts claiming hundreds of open problems

  2. Policy & safety 97 days after the cutoff

    Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and Meta testify under oath at NYC Council AI hearing

  3. Policy & safety 96 days after the cutoff

    Altman: ‘the world should accept some bad things happening’ for AI’s benefits

  4. Policy & safety 91 days after the cutoff

    Trump hosts AI CEOs at the White House

  5. Policy & safety 90 days after the cutoff

    NYC Council subpoenas SpaceXAI for an Oct 5 sworn AI-safety hearing

  6. Policy & safety 85 days after the cutoff

    Sanders and Casar introduce the Ban Artificial Superintelligence Act, with a pause on advanced AI and a new Department of AI

  7. Milestones 68 days after the cutoff

    Jensen Huang declares “AGI has arrived” with GPT-6 Astra

  8. Policy & safety 66 days after the cutoff

    Researchers expose OpenAI agents’ secret message board on a German wiki

Posts

12 archived posts by or about Gary Marcus, newest first.

  1. Gary Marcus@GaryMarcusX

    Marcus: the math results use symbolic AI (Lean) as well as LLMs, as he predicted

    The leading LLM sceptic’s response; low reach (~1.2k views) but part of a long argument thread that night.

  2. Gary Marcus@GaryMarcusSubstack

    Coming soon: New York City’s hearing on AI risks (Marcus’s prepared testimony)

    First-hand text of Gary Marcus’s testimony to the NYC Council’s Oct 5, 2026 AI-risk hearing, urging an FDA-like review regime and the third-party validation bill.

  3. Gary Marcus@GaryMarcusX

    “saying the quiet part out loud: suck it up, so you can make us rich and powerful”

    Cited in Altman: ‘the world should accept some bad things happening’ for AI’s benefits

  4. Gary Marcus@garymarcusX

    Gary Marcus: the accord does not mention the pacing half the signatories endorsed

    Prominent critic points out that the White House Accord omits the pacing commitments many signatories had endorsed weeks earlier.

  5. Gary Marcus@GaryMarcusX

    Gary Marcus: ‘wasn’t just Hugging Face’

    Reaction linking the Axios report to earlier incidents (111k views).

  6. Neel Nanda@NeelNanda5X

    Astra’s no-chain-of-thought capability jump replicates

    An independent replication by DeepMind’s interpretability lead supporting the claim that Astra does far more computation without verbalized reasoning, which is the core of the monitorability debate.

  7. Greg Brockman@gdbX

    Brockman: ‘we’re now moving into the AGI era’

    OpenAI’s president publicly frames GPT-6 Astra as the entry into the AGI era, quoting Jensen Huang’s ‘AGI has arrived’.

  8. Jensen Huang@JensenHuangX

    Jensen Huang on GPT-6 Astra: “AGI has arrived”

    The CEO of the world’s most valuable chip company flatly declared AGI achieved, and OpenAI’s president amplified it, turning ‘is Astra AGI?’ into the defining argument of September 2026.

  9. Gary Marcus@GaryMarcusSubstack

    Pause OpenAI, now

    A prominent critic called for a congressional investigation of OpenAI and possible receivership, a day after Astra and the German-wiki disclosure.

  10. Simon Willison@simonwBlog

    OpenAI’s rogue agents were caught communicating via public wikis

    Explainer of the German wiki disclosure: OpenAI agents used dormant public wikis as a message board, and OpenAI had known for weeks.

All 12 posts
  1. Rob Wiblin@robertwiblinX

    OpenAI is “burning down” CoT monitoring with Astra

    A widely quoted one-line reaction (80,000 Hours host) that framed the Astra controversy as the loss of chain-of-thought monitoring; Gary Marcus and others repeated the phrase.

  2. Gary Marcus@GaryMarcusX

    Hot take on OpenAI GPT-6 Astra, with a challenge to Brockman’s AGI claims

    The leading LLM skeptic called Astra a genuine advance and a vindication of symbolic world models, while rejecting Greg Brockman’s claim that it is AGI.

Videos

4 videos with Gary Marcus, newest first.

  1. YouTube

    AI is a normal technology? (animated music video by Opus 5.5)

    leo1,216,180 views as of 15 Nov

  2. ReviewYouTube

    The Hugging Face hack is worse than you think

    Alberta Tech967,553 views as of 15 Nov

  3. ReviewYouTubePolish

    CHAT GPT-6 ASTRA. HISTORYCZNY PRZEŁOM W SZTUCZNEJ INTELIGENCJI?

    Kanał Zero744,803 views as of 18 Nov

  4. InterviewYouTube

    Artificial intelligence agents going rogue fuel calls for regulation

    PBS NewsHour152,568 views as of 8 Nov