Marcus: the math results use symbolic AI (Lean) as well as LLMs, as he predicted
Gary Marcus @GaryMarcusX
Why it matters
The leading LLM sceptic’s response; low reach (~1.2k views) but part of a long argument thread that night.
Summary
Posted 01:25 UTC: OpenAI “uses symbolic AI (Lean, etc) in addition to LLMs which is what i said for years we would need to do”. In follow-ups he asked whether the system generates many attempts and filters them with Lean: “you give the monkeys and the typewriters all the credit?” (https://x.com/GaryMarcus/status/2107676825019420772), and called parts of the response a “condescending and scientifically ignorant cult” (https://x.com/GaryMarcus/status/2107680241120591887, ~4k views). Note: the README says not all results are Lean-formalized; whether Lean was used during search, not just for checking, is not stated.
Archived text
since problem are asking, for the math stuff openAI
- uses symbolic AI (Lean, etc) in addition to LLMs which is what i said for years we would need to do; this confirms what i actually said (as opposed to various fictitious misrepresentations that run rampant around here )
Quoting @hansaFL: So what do you think @GaryMarcus, just another brick in the wall?